VPR Header
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations
Programs

Is It Ever OK To Break A Rule?

iStock-833789384.jpg
833789384
/
istock
We talk ethics in this episode of But Why.

Is it OK to do something that you were told not to do and then never tell anybody? We tackle that question from 10-year-old Finn from Seattle. Also in this episode: why do people make really bad choices and want other people's lives to be harder?

Download our learning guides: PDF | Google Slide | Transcript

Loading...

We're tackling some ethical dilemmas in this episode and we're letting kids give the answers! We also get a response from ABC Radio's Short & Curly, a podcast devoted to ethics for kids.

And we hear from our listeners. Here's what some of you had to say:

"No, because it usually just means you get in trouble." - Juniper

"I think so. If you're protecting somebody or keeping a surprise." - Camille

"It depends who told you. Like if your parents told you, then you shouldn't do it. Or if you do it, you should tell them you did it. But if it's like a mean person you met on the street it's ok. And it depends what it is. Because if it's a bad question, you shouldn't do it either way if it's a bad thing. If it's a good deed you should do it. And if you did that, why wouldn't you tell anyone?" -Sylvie

"No, not really. If you don't tell anyone about it. It's mostly the doing it and then not telling anybody about it. Mostly what isn't the good thing about it. It's a little bit worse, if you don't tell someone you might get a feeling where you feel kind of embarrassed. And you don't tell anybody and it just sticks with you the rest of your life."  - Piper

Finn-Caleb-vpr-bodette-20170929.jpg
Credit courtesy from parents
Finn, left, 10, lives in Seattle, Wash. Caleb, 8, lives in Amherst, Mass.

Related Content